From
the Ends of the Earth
The United States Exploring Expedition Collections
Estimates
are that the collections amassed between April 1838 and June 1842 by the
United States Exploring Expedition, under the command of Charles Wilkes,
weighed nearly 40 tons. The naval officers, crew, and nine civilian scientists,
who sailed on six small ships for four years, gathered specimens of natural
history at nearly every stop, including several thousand zoological specimens,
50,000 plant specimens, thousands of shells, corals, fossils, and geological
specimens, even jars of sea water from different localities (Viola 1985:22).
They also collected 2,500 ethnological and archaeological specimens, which
they generally referred to as “curiosities,” to illustrate
the varied cultures with whom they came in contact.
The official collection
was first catalogued and exhibited in the Great Hall of the Patent Office
during the 1840s. In 1858 it was transferred by order of the United States
Congress to the Smithsonian Institution. The result of the transfer of
the government’s collections was the establishment of the United
States National Museum at the Smithsonian Institution, which until that
time had been devoted almost exclusively to research. Today, the specimens
constitute the core of nearly every collection in every scientific department
in the National Museum of Natural History. The “curiosities”
are in the collections of the Department of Anthropology, constituting
the earliest and, in some cases, rarest and most important objects the
Institution possesses. Despite the preciousness of this collection, Spencer
Baird began giving away sets of Exploring Expedition objects, which he
viewed as “duplicates,” as early as 1859. In the spirit of
James Smithson’s original mandate to increase and diffuse knowledge,
the Institution exchanged more than 500 objects, which found their way
to more than forty museums in the United States, Canada, and Europe.
The officers, crew
members, and scientists, known to the crew as “the scientifics”
all participated in gathering the anthropological artifacts. The principal
scientific collectors included the two naturalists Charles Pickering,
a physician, and Titian Ramsay Peale, an artist and museologist; the geologist,
James Dwight Dana; and Horatio Hale, a recent Harvard graduate, who was
a linguist and philologist. William Rich and William Dunlop Brackenridge,
the botanist and horticulturist on board, also collected artifacts, as
did Joseph Drayton and Alfred T. Agate, the expedition’s artist
and illustrator.
The scientifics were
so industrious that their collections began to crowd and overwhelm the
vessels’ already cramped quarters. Officers and crew alike complained
about the smell of dead birds, animals, and fishes, along with the odor
of mollusks and plants being dried and preserved. One solution to this
problem was to bundle specimens for shipment home via American sailing
vessels met along the way. When their voyage had only just begun, the
expedition shipped some 50,000 specimens from Rio de Janeiro. The government
in Washington was not prepared to deal with the vast scope of the collections,
lacking the space to store them or the personnel to care for them. In
the beginning the government seemed to take little interest in the specimens,
distributing them to a variety of scientists for their personal collections.
This seemed expedient since there was no museum of any size or significance
in Washington that could handle the amount of material being shipped home
by the expedition.
The shipping
lists and bills of lading presented to the government by numerous sailing
vessels carrying the Exploring Expedition’s collections give an
idea of the variety and quantity of material shipped home by the scientifics.
These lists are now housed in the Smithsonian Institution Archives. One
example is a bill of lading from the schooner Palestine, lying
in New York harbor in April 1841, bound for Washington City. It carried
the following freight for the government: “Twenty five boxes and
ten barrels of shells; twenty five boxes and one barrel containing botanical
and other specimens; Seven boxes containing curiosities from Fiji Islands;
One box containing seeds and roots and eight boxes containing coral; One
box containing Deep Sea water. One Fiji Drum; Thirty-six bundles and one
Box containing spears and clubs; One box containing wheat. One box containing
flower seeds; One box containing log books, one box containing a sleigh;
One box containing books for philological department.” The bill
for this freight was $55.60, figured at the rate of ten cents per cubic
foot; thus the Palestine had stored and shipped 556 cubit feet
of Ex Ex collections (SIA RU 7058).
As the amount of material arriving at American ports began to reach overflow
capacity, the stop-gap solutions initially applied became increasingly
problematic, and the difficulty of keeping track of the collections became
evident. Joel Roberts Poinsett, the first U.S. ambassador to Mexico and
the outgoing Secretary of the Navy, from the beginning closely involved
with the expedition, had founded the National Institution for the Promotion
of Science in 1840. Poinsett and what became known as the National Institute
offered to take charge of the rapidly expanding Exploring Expedition (often
referred to as Ex Ex or Exp. Exp.) collections, arranging for them to
be housed in the newly completed Patent Office building. The Ex Ex collections
dwarfed all other government collections, and while they were initially
curated by the National Institute, the institute’s involvement was
quickly dispensed with when the Expedition returned in the summer of 1842.
Reclaiming the fruits of their efforts, the scientific gentlemen, headed
by Charles Pickering, began to unpack, sort, and catalogue the material
that they had carefully labeled and listed. William Brackenridge the botanist,
Horatio Hale the philologist, and James Dana the geologist eventually
joined Pickering in this effort. Together, they began the tasks of listing
and numbering birds, reptiles, fishes, quadrupeds, and curiosities (Evelyn
1985:234). Pickering resigned as chief curator in 1843, when Charles Wilkes
took command of the entire Exploring Expedition collection, making certain
that all specimens were scientifically arranged and beautifully displayed
in newly purchased glass cases.
In 1846 the U.S. Congress created the Smithsonian Institution, in response
to the $500,000 dollar bequest of James Smithson, and within a very few
years began pressuring it to take charge of all of the government’s
collections. The Institution’s first Secretary, Joseph Henry, resisted
the inevitability of acquiring the enormous collections amassed by the
government, principally because his vision for the Smithsonian was that
of a research center. In contrast, Spencer Fullerton Baird, who became
Henry’s assistant, dreamed of the Smithsonian’s becoming the
National Museum of the United States. Baird had written to James Dana
in 1849, hoping for a job recommendation to the Smithsonian Secretary.
Dana cautioned Baird that, as he understood it, the Secretary was not
looking for a curator and “wanted nothing to do with the Exp. Exp.
collections, or any other government property.” Dana, presumably
aware that he was preaching to the choir, continued, “ I regret
that he takes this stand - for collections are better than books to the
naturalist, they contain the whole that was ever put in words on the subjects
they illustrate a thousand times more" (RU 7002, SIA, Box 19).
In 1857 the U.S. Congress transferred the government’s collections
in their entirety to the Smithsonian Institution, along with $15,000 for
the “construction and erection of exhibit cases, $2,000 to cover
the cost of moving the specimens, and an annual appropriation of $4,000”
(Reingold & Rothenberg 1985:250). The Exploring Expedition collection,
also known as the Wilkes collection, represented the largest single collection
belonging to the people of the United States. In terms of the Smithsonian
Institution’s collections, it represents the earliest collected
material in nearly every department in the National Museum of Natural
History, including botany, geology, vertebrates, invertebrates, and anthropology.
The handwritten catalogue from the Patent Office, entitled “Collections
of the United States South Sea Surveying and Exploring Expedition, 1838,
9, 40, 41, & 42” is now in the Department of Anthropology’s
National Anthropological Archives. It contains 2,487 entries with 29 duplicate
numbers for a total of 2,516 ethnological and archaeological specimens.
The collection covers most of the world they explored -- North and South
America, Asia, Australia, Polynesia, Micronesia and Melanesia, including
the island groups of Hawaii, New Zealand, Fiji, Tonga, Samoa, Tahiti,
the Tuamotus and many others.
Titian Peale presented his copy of the catalogue to the United States
National Museum in 1877. More than a century later, when I began to reassemble
the original official collection with Adrienne Kaeppler, I realized my
Smithsonian predecessors, who’d catalogued the Patent Office collections
beginning in 1859, hadn’t had access to Peale’s catalogue.
It appears that the government’s collections were listed and described
in the order in which they were unpacked after the transfer. Employing
the original Smithsonian inventories contained in the first three volumes
of handwritten ledgers begun in March 1859, I attempted to construct a
master list of Exploring Expedition objects. The Smithsonian ledgers record
all the ethnological and archaeological collections, but do so in no apparent
order. Some artifacts are grouped together in collections; for instance,
30 or 40 objects collected in Japan by Matthew Perry are followed by 20
or so royal gifts from the King of Siam, then the Perry collection picks
up again. The first object collected by the Exploring Expedition is number
759, which is then followed by a series of artifacts collected by the
National Institute and a variety of other collectors. The second Ex. Ex.
artifact doesn’t appear until number 1359.
The ledgers yielded a list of nearly 2,000 catalogue numbers describing
Exploring Expedition objects, with which storage locations could then
be associated. In the 1980s, the Department of Anthropology’s entire
collection was housed in the National Museum of Natural History, in cabinets
stacked three high in the hallways outside research offices, in the single
climate controlled room located on the fifth floor of the east wing, and
in storage units scattered throughout the basement and several vast rooms
in the building’s attic. Once I located the objects with the assistance
of several interns, I began the task of associating each artifact with
its original description and number in the Peale catalogue. This original
catalogue became the collection’s bible since, unlike the Smithsonian
catalogue, it was organized by the country or region where each artifact
was collected, as well as by artifact type.
Titian Peale’s catalogue begins with an enumeration of human remains
collected by the Expedition throughout the world, including three Peruvian
mummies from Arica and Pachacamac and a variety of crania and other skeletal
remains from Hawaii, Fiji, Oregon, and California. It lists the cranium
of Veindovi, the Fijian chief of the island of Kantavu, whom Wilkes had
taken prisoner for the crime of cannibalism. Veindovi had died hours after
arriving in New York, where his body was buried, but they added his skull
to the Ex.Ex. collection. They collected another Fijian skull from a native
group who had recently feasted on it, constituting the Ex. Ex.’s
physical proof of this much-feared Fijian custom. There are also two preserved,
tattooed Maori heads from New Zealand, which Charles Wilkes purchased
from a British vessel in the Bay of Islands.
Despite the fact that Peale’s listing of anthropological material
contains only a few items from Asia, these are the first curiosities mentioned.
In Singapore the expedition obtained models of Bugis pirate sailing ships,
a number of Javanese knives and daggers called krises, and Malay
baskets and coins. They also collected one large, round, wooden shield,
several war spears, and a musical instrument from the Sooloo islands in
the Philippines. Hatchets, known as head axes, and swords came from Luzon.
Peale also lists a Siamese shirt made of slips of bamboo, which has never
been located. Dr. Judd of Honolulu provided Japanese clothing, writing
implements, coins, chopsticks, books and medicine for the Expedition’s
collection. He obtained them from the shipwrecked crew of a Japanese vessel,
rescued in the north Pacific. The coins and medicinal products were transferred
to the divisions of numismatics and history of medicine in the National
Museum of American History.
Another artifact, presented to the Expedition at Honolulu, was a dog sled
from the island of Kamchatka. Captain Joy of the ship Hero from
Nantucket donated it to the official collection, and it is the sled listed
on the Palentine’s bill of lading, and is unique in the
Department of Anthropology’s collections.
The expedition collected North American material along the California,
Oregon, and Washington coast before any of these territories belonged
to the United States. The most common items are about 80 bows and arrows
and dozens of eel and halibut hooks. They obtained colorful blankets and
belts woven of sheep’s wool and dog hair from the Salish, and carved
wooden combs used in weaving. Tightly woven cedar bark capes with sea
otter trim from the Classet people of the Oregon Territories were prized,
along with full-size canoe paddles and a variety of model canoes, kayaks
and cradles. The scientists collected dentalium shell necklaces, beautifully
woven baskets and mats and dice made from beaver teeth for a gambling
game. Carved and painted wooden masks from this northern region represent
women with lip plugs and nose ornaments; the scientists wrote the latitude
at which they were collected in sepia ink on each of them.
In California they collected two extraordinary feather blankets made from
iridescent feathers of water fowl somewhere in the vicinity of Johan Suter’s
(aka John Sutter) fort, along with a raven feather cape and dance headdress
collected near San Francisco. These are some of the rarest and most beautiful
objects from the North American continent. To my knowledge there are only
three raven feather capes is museum collections, and the California feather
blankets are 2 of 14 in the world (McLendon 2001:132). When I first saw
the feather blanket, neatly folded in a drawer in the attic, I initially
thought it couldn’t possibly be part of the Ex Ex collection because
it looked brand new and in perfect condition. Other treasures are items
made of waterproof seal intestine, decorated with feathers and otter skins,
including one extraordinary Aleut cape made to look like a Russian military
cape. They brought back dishes and smoking pipes carved from argillite,
a kind of black slate, with carvings like those on totem poles. Other
pipes were made of wood and bone, and depict peaceful scenes of people
in wooden houses surrounded by picket fences. Hudsons Bay Company employees
donated masks and one beautiful painted rattle, carved in the shape of
a bird.
Titian Peale listed the South American objects after the North American
collection despite the fact that these were the first artifacts the Expedition
collected. As they sailed down the east coast of South America, the Scientifics
made a small, but significant collection in Tierra del Fuego. They bartered
for tools, bows and arrows, fish spears, shell and bird-bone necklaces
and other ornaments with Fuegians, whom they encountered in dugout canoes
along the coast. The canoes, to the surprise of all, were filled with
scantily clothed people who sat around small fires in the boats to keep
warm. On the Pacific coast of South America, near Lima, Peru, they obtained
archaeological materials from excavations at the pre-Columbian site of
Pachacamac. Additionally, they purchased native clothing and saddle accouterments
in Chile and Peru. A few of the “pre-Columbian” ceramic vessels
that they purchased in Lima shops turn out to be early 19th-century copies.
In New Zealand expedition members gathered numerous embroidered cloaks
woven by Maoris from native flax, nephrite adornments called heitikis,
carved wooden boxes and staffs, stone clubs called patus, and
an elaborately carved and painted canoe prow. At the Bay of Islands, the
captain of a whaling ship from Boston presented them with some fifty bows
and arrows from Bougainville in the Solomon Islands. Each of these bows
has “NEW ZEALAND” written on it in white ink, initially causing
some confusion, since the Maori are among the only people of the world
who never used bows and arrows.
From Australia, the young philologist Horatio Hale shipped home a small,
but relatively complete, collection of Aboriginal material culture including
boomerangs, clubs, spears and spear throwers, two wooden shields, and
one beautifully decorated cloak made from the skins of 23 opossums and
one kangaroo. The cloaks were also used in burials, and as a result are
exceedingly rare artifacts. It is one of only seven in existence (Kaeppler
1985:122)
In the myriad South Pacific islands, they collected a wide variety of
fishing gear, including bone and shell hooks, fishing lines and nets made
from woven and twisted vegetable fibers, along with basketry, mats, adornments,
and household implements from Searles, Clermont Tonnerre, and the Disappointment
Islands of the Tuamotuan group. At Kingsmille Island, the expedition encountered
fearsome warriors. They were dressed in armor made of sticks wrapped with
coconut fiber cordage and wore helmets made from the skins of porcupine
fish. Here, they collected knives, swords, and spears shaped like tritons,
all made with razor-sharp sharks teeth lashed in rows onto wooden shafts.
On Penrhyns Island they collected necklaces made from tightly woven and
twisted human hair. One sample of beautifully decorated bark cloth from
Tahiti is stenciled with delicate fern leaf designs.
More than thirty large pieces of decorated tapa, or cloth made
from the pounded inner bark of the paper mulberry tree, were collected
in Hawaii, along with tortoiseshell fish hooks, fishing lines and nets,
and stone adzes and chisels. In addition to the usual shell and stone
implements, Hawaiians produced poi pounders, or stone pestles,
used to make their national dish, and ulu maika, which were stone
disks for a popular game. Complimenting the painted and beautifully decorated
tapa are examples of bark cloth in varying stages of production,
along with carved and incised wooden bark pounders used in their manufacture.
Alfred Agate, the expedition artist, sketched a scene of a group of women
in the communal activity of pounding out bark cloth in unison (Kaeppler
1985:128). Large calabash gourd containers, some of which were used on
the expedition’s climb up Mount Kilauea, and a smaller, canteenlike
water gourd appear in Peale’s catalogue, along with bunches of yellow
feathers (paid as tax to chiefs), and human-hair necklaces with carved
whale or walrus ivory ornaments called pelaoas, which are uniquely
Hawaiian. One of these necklaces, Titian Peale noted, was “formerly
the property of Madam Boki, wife of Governor Boki, who accompanied King
Tamahamaha [Kamehameha] on his visit to England in the year 1823. [It
was] presented to the Expedition by William French, Esqr. Honolulu Nov
30, 1840.” Charles Wilkes made a small collection of items produced
by Hawaiian children, who were being educated in Christian missionary
schools. The objects, he believed, would illustrate their industry and
the civilizing influence of the missionaries. Off the Island of Hawaii,
the scientifics also collected several fragments of the rock on which
the great English explorer, Captain James Cook, had been killed more than
a half-century before.
In Tonga, the Friendly Islands, they found coconut -fiber fly whisks,
combs, fans, beautiful, and finely woven mats made of pandanus, a type
of screw pine tree with dagger like leaves. These mats are very highly
valued by Tongans and are passed down from generation to generation. The
expedition also brought back graceful, wooden, neck rests and a beautifully
carved, wooden bowl in the shape of a double out-rigger canoe, which was
used for holding coconut body oil.
In Samoa they amassed piles of shaggy mats woven from hibiscus fiber,
very different from the fine Tongan mats. The shaggy mats came in an off
white and a deep reddish brown color. They also collected about 60 large
pieces of bark cloth, many of them painted in solid colors and individually
decorated, some used as ponchos, and others as wraparound skirts. The
Samoan collection also includes large, wooden bowls for mixing the drink
kava, neck rests, outrigger models, bamboo nose flutes, pigeon
arrows and pigeon roosts, fans, fishing lines by the dozens, and numerous
spears and war clubs.
Titian Peale left the largest and most important part of the collection
for last; with number 1285 he began a list of more than 1200 artifacts
collected in the Fiji Islands. It was perhaps the least known and most
forbidding place they visited. They spent more than four months exploring,
mapping, and recording Fijian customs. It was also the place where tragedy
struck the expedition when two of their crew were killed in a battle with
islanders.
The official collections contain 120 Fijian skirts or broad belts woven
from grasses, swamp sedge, hibiscus fibers, and strips of pandanus leaves
(Clunie 1986:156), in addition to more than 150 examples of bark cloth
used as clothing, covers, room dividers and, in its most finely beaten
varieties, as turbans to protect the natives’ carefully coifed hair.
The expedition managed to acquire rare carved wooden idols, large wooden
kava bowls for the ritual drink of the same name, and a provision
safe--a large wooden hook covered by a flat disk used for suspending food
out of the reach of rodents. Fijians made highly individualistic glazed
pottery in a large variety of unusual shapes, including drinking vessels
that appear to represent outrigger canoes. The Ex. Ex. collected a large
assortment of ornaments and jewelry made mostly of shell, although several
necklaces are composed of individually strung human teeth. A huge drum
(or slit gong) carved from a hollowed-out tree trunk was carried back
to the United States on the Palestine, along with other musical
instruments, including bamboo nose flutes.
Fijians took great care with their hair, and expedition members made a
point of collecting combs, hair picks (some as long as 18 inches), feathered
headbands, and even wigs. Titian Peale noted that when relatives died,
Fijian mourners were required to cut off their hair, and at the end of
mourning, theey wore wigs until the hair grew back. There are also two,
rare, ceremonial masks, with faces made of coconut bast and tightly curled
human hair. They collected woven palm-leaf mats, sun shades that look
like oversized fans, and actual fans, along with about 45 flat, woven,
wallet-like baskets used to carry tobacco leaves.
The previously listed items account for approximately two-thirds of the
Expedition’s Fijian collection. The remaining third consists of
some 450 weapons, many of which they presumably collected during several
deadly battles with Fijian warriors. These include more than a hundred
large, often intricately carved, war clubs, some of which may have been
insignias of office or rank. In addition to those weapons captured in
battle, Fijians presented some of the larger clubs to the Expedition’s
officers as a initial gesture of friendship following the performance
of a club dance in Vanua Levu (Kaeppler 1985:123-125). Peale lists an
impressively large variety of more than two hundred iulas or
throwing clubs; these weapons were called “handy billies”
by Ex Ex crew members. Fijians used them in battle to stun their victims,
moving in later for the kill with the larger, heavier war clubs. One musket
was also collected at Mololo, where Charles Wilkes’s nephew, Wilkes
Henry, and Lt. Joseph Underwood were killed; the musket’s stock
is covered with the same intricate carving the clubs display. Sixty war
spears, some as long as 18 feet, and about 130 bows and arrows fill out
the impressive inventory of Fijian armaments. One of the final items listed
in Titian Peale’s catalogue is a headdress that was presented to
the expedition by the king of Somo Somo, a Fiji island state, in 1840.
Locating all the items described in Peale’s catalogue and associating
his numbers with objects bearing Smithsonian catalogue numbers took many,
many months of reassembling the official collection. Since the anthropology
collections are arranged geographically and by culture, the Exploring
Expedition objects were stored in cabinets widely distributed throughout
the Museum of Natural History. After more than a century of storage and
exhibition, many of the objects had lost their identifying marks, their
Peale numbers, their Smithsonian catalogue numbers, and any labels that
might have been glued on or attached in some manner. After months of opening
cabinets and searching for objects, my interns and I developed a familiarity
with the type and look of the Expedition collections. I found that I could
identify many artifacts simply from type, appearance, even a particular
patina, often despite a lack of numerical confirmation, . Sometimes, we
were able to identify items with the help of modern technology. For instance,
one of my principal interns, Molly Coxson, and I would use ultraviolet
and infrared light to bring out numbers, initials, or other identifying
marks written in sepia-colored ink, which had long ago been absorbed by
the wood.
Eventually I discovered that about a third of the collection, nearly 800
objects, seemed to be missing. Reading through annual reports of the National
Museum from the 1860s and 1870s, I found numerous references to an “Office
of Distribution,” as well as lists of natural history specimens
and items of “ethnologica” it had disbursed. The records of
this defunct office, now housed in the Smithsonian Institution Archives,
provided an explanation for the missing and unaccounted for portion of
the collection. Spencer Baird set up the office to fulfill James Smithson’s
mandate of increasing and diffusing knowledge. Baird, a naturalist, had
formed large collections of natural history specimens, widely trading
duplicate specimens of his own. In the 1850s he embarked upon the task
of broadening the Smithsonian’s collections by exchanging what he
viewed as duplicate specimens for specimens the Institution lacked.
Interestingly enough, one of the first gifts of Exploring Expedition objects
was a series of Fijian war clubs, decorated bark cloth, and grass skirts
sent to Charles Erskine, who is featured in Nathaniel Philbrick’s
Seas of Glory. Erskine had once been Charles Wilkes’s cabin
boy and had served as an ordinary seaman during the entire Exploring Expedition
voyage. He received these artifacts early in 1859, not long after they
had been transferred from the Patent Office, but before they had been
catalogued in the Smithsonian. Erskine was living in Roxbury, Massachusetts,
at the time, and his collection eventually found its way to the Peabody
Museum in Salem, where the artifacts were identified by their original
Peale numbers.
The Distribution Office ledger provided a record of some 25 sets of artifacts
that had been chosen from the main collection, assembled, listed, packed,
and sent to museums, universities, and state cabinets of natural history
beginning in 1867. The page which lists these sets is entitled, "Distribution
of Miscellaneous series of Curiosities,” consisting of “N.
W. Coast Arrows & bows; Fejee clubs & cloth; Fejee baskets, shell
bracelets, etc. in each about 14 specimens contained in a long neat box
(see invoice for numbers)" (SIA RU:7058). The only “Fejee”
artifacts the Institution had in 1867 belonged to the Exploring Expedition’s
collection, and this single page now explained why at least 350 objects
were missing from the attic, and gave indications of their present whereabouts
as well. The same ledger, a few pages later, listed the Royal Ethnological
Museum in Copenhagen as the recipient of 188 "Polynesian and Esquimaux"
specimens and, below this, the Chicago Academy of Sciences, the recipient
of about 100 more.
In 1983 I sent a series of letters requesting information about the exchanged
artifacts, and eventually received replies and photographs from museums
throughout the United States, Canada, and Europe. The similarities among
these l867 museum starter kits were truly striking, and in most cases,
one could see why Spencer Baird considered them to be duplicates. Each
set consisted of an eel or halibut hook with a bow and arrows from Washington,
Oregon, or northern California (these two classes of objects were the
only North American artifacts collected in any great number); a selection
of Fijian war clubs, usually two or four large ones and two or three smaller
throwing clubs or iulas; one Fijian grass skirt (out of total
130); one Fijian shell bracelet, one Fijian basket (a generous act since
there were originally only 40), a Bougainville bow and arrows, nearly
all of which bore the NEW ZEALAND notation, some Polynesian fish hooks;
and a selection of tapa, mostly from Samoa and Fiji. The tapa pieces often
appear to be sections of much larger samples, which had been cut up; sometimes
several institutions reported the same catalogue number for their piece
of tapa, and photographs indicate that they came from the same item.
Some responses recorded the multiplicity of problems facing l9th-century
collections, fire being a particularly serious one. An Exploring Expedition
set sent to Amherst College in l867 was destroyed by a fire in the l880s;
another sent to the University of Toronto burned up a decade later. But
the worst tragedy to befall the Expedition’s diffused collections
was the Great Chicago Fire, when more than fifty Exploring Expedition
artifacts sent to the Academy of Sciences in l867 went up in flames in
l871.
The good news was that most of the sets that hadn’t met an untimely
end still existed. The Royal Ethnological Museum in Copenhagen, now the
National Museum of Denmark still holds nearly the entire inventory of
Exploring Expedition objects that it received in 1867, except for a few
pieces they themselves exchanged with other museums. Their “duplicate”
collection contains several unique artifacts, however, including a Fijian
“oracle”--a carved coconut covered with red seeds. They were
also the recipients of the other California feather blanket collected
near Sutter’s fort.
As time went by we were able to account for more and more of the missing
pieces. Some museums and university collections had lost documentation
regarding their sets, and appreciated the data now being supplied them.
More missing objects also turned up in the attic of the Natural History
building, with the help of George Washington University interns and the
aid of ultraviolet and infrared light. Occasionally, these examinations
brought to light the signature of the objects collector, TRP (Titian Peale)
or WMW (William Walker, the ships purser), or CW (Charles Wilkes), and
occasionally a note in the Charles Pickering’s fine hand. On some
wooden artifacts, clubs, bowls, plates and the like, interns and I discovered
under ultraviolet light examination entire sentences, even paragraphs,
written on them supplying details of when, where, and by whom they were
first collected. Occasionally, ultraviolet or black light revealed a number
completely different from what was prominently displayed on the surface,
and upon further research we discovered that some artifacts had been catalogued
more than once. One such catalogue number was listed in the ledger with
the explanation that the original number had been lost; so this artifact
was assigned a new number, and then "reentered to avoid confusion."
Exploring Expedition artifacts over the century had become mixed up in
storage, with some objects misidentified as to culture or region of origin.
For example, we found two cedar bark cloaks from the North West Coast
of North America in a miscellaneous section of African storage. And as
familiarity with the collection increased, we located pieces of broken
artifacts in what were known as “hospital drawers” in storage
cabinets, which we then reattached or at least reassociated with the original
artifact. One of the most interesting objects to regain its identity was
the headdress presented by the king of Somo Somo. It rested in a wooden
tray, a jumbled pile bark cloth strips wound around reeds, some with remnants
of feathers, and intertwined with coconut-fiber cord and bark cloth cut
into fringe. A handwritten note from Robert Elder, a Department of Anthropology
collections specialist for many decades, accompanied this artifact. Mr.
Elder wrote that he had found a corner of an old label tied to the object,
which he believed to be one of the old printed Exploring Expedition labels.
Having come across a drawing of the headdress in Volume III of the published
Narrative, I presented the wooden tray of bark cloth tubes to Cathy Valentour,
a Department of Anthropology conservator, and asked her if they might
be part of the headdress. At first dubious, she eventually was able to
restore and reconstruct this unique headdress, using the drawing as a
guide.
While the passage of 150 years has taken some toll on the Exploring Expedition’s
anthropological and archaeological collection, it is a tribute to the
Smithsonian Institution and the National Museum of Natural History’s
long legacy of stewardship that so many of these objects can still be
studied and appreciated today. Objects of exceeding rarity, beauty, and
fragility, such as the California feather blankets, the seal-gut cape
bordered with otter fur, piles of finely decorated, pliant bark cloth,
intricately woven grass skirts and mats, as well as flax-and cedar-bark
blankets were never meant to last more than a few years at most; certainly
not more than 170 years! As James Dana wrote in 1849, these unique and
valuable collections are indeed “better than books.” The collections
are the tangible result and product of the first government-sponsored
scientific expedition, and represent as well the diligent care, hard work,
and research of many generations of Smithsonian curators, specialists,
conservators, and technicians who safeguarded this legacy for future generations.
Bibliography
Clunie, Fergus
1986 Yalo i Viti Shades of Viti: A Fiji Museum Catalogue. Fiji
Museum, Suva.
Evelyn, Douglas E
1985 The National Gallery at the Patent Office in Magnificent Voyagers.
The U.S. Exploring Expedition, 1838-1842. Smithsonian Institution
Press, Washington, D.C.
Kaeppler,
Adrienne L.
1985 Anthropology and the U.S. Exploring Expedition in Magnificent
Voyagers. The U.S. Exploring Expedition, 1838-1842. Smithsonian Institution
Press, Washington, D.C.
Sally McLendon
2001 California Feather Blankets: Objects of wealth and status in two
19th century worlds. Studies in American Indian Art: A Memorial Tribute
to Norman Feder. Christian Feest, ed. European Review of Native
American Studies Monograph II. Seattle: University of Washington
Press, pp. 132-161.
Philbrick,
Nathaniel
2003 Sea of Glory: America’s Voyage of Discovery The U.S. Exploring
Expedition, 1838-1842. Viking.
Viola, Herman
J & Carolyn Margolis
1985 Magnificent Voyagers. The U.S. Exploring Expedition, 1838-1842. Smithsonian
Institution Press, Washington, D.C.
Viola, Herman J
1985 The Story of the U.S. Exploring Expedition in Magnificent Voyagers.
The U.S. Exploring Expedition, 1838-1842. Smithsonian Institution
Press, Washington, D.C.
Walsh, Jane
MacLaren
2002 Collections as Currency in Anthropology, History, and American
Indians: Essays in Honor of William Curtis Sturtevant. Editors William
L. Merrill and Ives Goddard. Smithsonian Contributions to Anthropology
- Number 44. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D.C.
Dr.
Jane Walsh
Museum Specialist
Anthropology Outreach Office
Department of Anthropology
National Museum of Natural History
March 29, 2004
|